VerticalResponse vs Mailigen: The Best Email Marketing Tool for You

Hey there! Are you in a dilemma trying to decide between VerticalResponse and Mailigen for your email marketing needs? You’re not alone. With so many tools out there, it can be a real head-scratcher to pick the right one. But worry not, because today, we’re diving deep into these two popular platforms. We’ll dissect their features, ease of use, pricing, and much more. By the end of this article, you’ll have a crystal-clear picture of which tool fits your needs like a glove. So, grab a coffee, and let’s get started!

VerticalResponse	Mailigen
G2 Score – 3.3 out of 5 stars	G2 Score – Nil
TrustRadius Score -10.0 out of 10	TrustRadius Score – 7.1 out of 10

Ease of Use: Navigating the User Interface

First things first, let’s talk about usability. Because, let’s face it, if you’re wrestling with a tool more than using it, what’s the point, right?

VerticalResponse: Simplicity at its Best

VerticalResponse prides itself on being user-friendly. Right from the get-go, you’re greeted with a clean, intuitive dashboard. For newcomers, this is a breath of fresh air. You don’t want to spend hours just figuring out where everything is. Here, it’s all laid out neatly. The drag-and-drop functionality in their campaign builder is a game-changer. It allows you to create professional-looking emails without needing a degree in design. This simplicity extends to their contact management system too. Uploading and organizing your contact list is as straightforward as it gets.

Mailigen: Slightly Steeper Learning Curve

Mailigen, on the other hand, while not overly complicated, has a bit more of a learning curve. The interface is packed with features, which is great, but it can be a tad overwhelming for new users. The dashboard is well-organized, but with more bells and whistles than VerticalResponse, it takes a bit more time to navigate confidently. That said, once you get the hang of it, Mailigen reveals its true potential. The level of customization and automation it offers is impressive. And for those who love diving into data, Mailigen’s reporting tools are top-notch.

Crafting Your First Email Campaign

Let’s talk about building your first email campaign. You want this process to be as smooth and hiccup-free as possible.

VerticalResponse: For the Quick Starters

VerticalResponse makes creating your first campaign almost too easy. Select a template, drag and drop elements, tweak the text, and you’re good to go. It’s perfect for those who need to get a campaign up and running without fuss. The templates are plentiful and varied, catering to different styles and industries. Plus, the ability to preview and test your emails ensures you don’t send out anything less than perfect.

Mailigen: Flexibility for the Creatives

Mailigen steps up with a robust email builder. It offers more customization options compared to VerticalResponse. This is where creativity can truly shine. You can start from scratch or use a template as a base. The flexibility here is a big plus for those who have a specific vision for their emails. However, this flexibility means you might spend a bit more time crafting your campaign. But for those who value customization, it’s time well spent.

The Verdict: Ease of Use

If you’re all about simplicity and getting things done quickly, VerticalResponse is your go-to. Its straightforward approach means you spend less time learning and more time doing. For those who crave deeper customization and don’t mind a bit of a learning curve, Mailigen is the way to go.

Feature Set: Diving into the Capabilities

Now, let’s shift gears and talk about the features. After all, the right tools can make or break your email marketing strategy.

VerticalResponse: The Essentials Covered

VerticalResponse offers a suite of essential features that cater to most basic email marketing needs. You’ve got your email campaign creation, contact management, and basic automation. One standout feature is their social media integration. It allows you to extend your reach beyond just email. You can post directly to your social media channels and even create social media-specific campaigns. Another plus is their survey feature, enabling you to gather valuable feedback from your audience. However, if you’re looking for advanced automation and segmentation, VerticalResponse might feel a bit limiting.

Mailigen: A Playground for Marketers

Mailigen is like a Swiss Army knife for email marketers. It’s packed with features that cater to a range of needs. Advanced segmentation and automation are where Mailigen really shines. You can create complex workflows based on subscriber behavior, ensuring your emails are as relevant as possible. Their integration options are also worth noting. From CRM systems to e-commerce platforms, Mailigen plays well with others, making it a versatile choice for diverse marketing ecosystems. Additionally, their SMS marketing feature is a unique addition that can amplify your reach.

Building Relationships with Automation

Automation is the secret sauce in email marketing. It saves time and personalizes the experience for your audience.

VerticalResponse: Keeping it Simple

VerticalResponse’s automation tools are straightforward. You can set up basic autoresponders for welcome emails, birthday greetings, and other trigger-based messages. This works well for keeping your audience engaged without needing constant manual intervention. However, if you’re looking to create complex, behavior-driven email sequences, you might find VerticalResponse a bit underpowered.

Mailigen: Sophistication in Automation

Mailigen’s automation capabilities are robust. You can create intricate email sequences that react to how your subscribers interact with your emails. This level of personalization can significantly increase engagement and conversions. Whether it’s re-engaging dormant subscribers or nurturing leads through different stages, Mailigen’s automation tools are up to the task.

Analyzing Success: Reporting and Analytics

What’s email marketing without some solid data to back up your strategies?

VerticalResponse offers decent reporting features. You get insights into open rates, click-through rates, and social media engagement metrics. These reports are easy to understand and provide enough data for small to medium-sized businesses to make informed decisions.

Mailigen goes a step further in analytics. You get detailed reports on almost every aspect of your campaigns. From geo-tracking to click heat maps, the data available is extensive. For data-driven marketers, this level of detail is invaluable.

The Verdict: Feature Set

If you need a straightforward, no-fuss tool that covers the essentials, VerticalResponse is a great fit. But if you’re looking for a feature-rich platform that allows for complex strategies and provides detailed insights, Mailigen is your ally.

Pricing and Plans: Balancing Cost and Value

Choosing the right tool also means finding something that fits your budget. Let’s break down the pricing structures of VerticalResponse and Mailigen to see which offers more bang for your buck.

VerticalResponse: Affordable Simplicity

VerticalResponse offers a straightforward pricing model. They have a free plan, which is great for small businesses or individuals just starting out. This plan includes basic features like email creation and reporting. As your needs grow, you can upgrade to their paid plans, which are reasonably priced and based on the number of contacts in your list. One attractive aspect of VerticalResponse’s pricing is its transparency – there are no hidden costs, and you get what you pay for.

Mailigen: Flexible but Pricier

Mailigen’s pricing is a bit more complex. They don’t offer a free plan, but their starting price is accessible for small businesses. The cost increases as your subscriber list grows, similar to VerticalResponse. However, Mailigen tends to be on the pricier side, especially as you tap into more advanced features and larger contact lists. That said, the range of features and capabilities you get with Mailigen can justify the higher price, especially for medium to large businesses or those with more sophisticated email marketing strategies.

Evaluating Value for Money

It’s not just about the price; it’s about what you get for that price.

VerticalResponse: Ideal for Budget-Conscious Users

For those watching their budget, VerticalResponse offers good value. The basic features it provides are more than sufficient for straightforward email marketing campaigns. If your needs are simple and you’re not looking for advanced automation or segmentation, VerticalResponse can be a cost-effective choice.

Mailigen: More Features, Higher Cost

Mailigen, with its broader feature set, offers good value for those who will utilize its advanced capabilities. If you’re a power user or a business that relies heavily on email marketing, the investment in Mailigen can be worthwhile. The advanced automation, detailed analytics, and extensive integration options can provide a significant return on investment for the right user.

The Verdict: Pricing and Plans

VerticalResponse is your go-to for affordability and basic needs. If you’re just dipping your toes into email marketing or have a tight budget, it’s a solid choice. On the other hand, if you’re ready to dive deep into advanced email marketing tactics and need a tool that can keep up, Mailigen, despite being pricier, offers the comprehensive features that can cater to complex marketing needs.

Customer Support: When You Need a Helping Hand

Imagine this: you’re in the middle of a crucial email campaign, and something goes awry. What do you do? That’s where customer support comes into play.

VerticalResponse: Reliable Assistance

VerticalResponse offers solid customer support. They provide email support, and you can expect timely responses to your inquiries. They also have an extensive knowledge base with articles, guides, and tutorials to help you troubleshoot common issues. While they don’t offer 24/7 live chat support, their support team is known for being helpful and responsive during business hours.

Mailigen: Comprehensive Support

Mailigen takes customer support seriously. They offer email and live chat support during business hours, which can be a lifesaver when you encounter urgent issues. Additionally, they have a phone support option, which is a rarity among email marketing providers. Their knowledge base is rich with resources, and they even offer onboarding assistance for new users to ensure a smooth start.

Community and Resources

Sometimes, you don’t need to reach out to support; you can find answers in the community or through self-help resources.

VerticalResponse: Growing Community

VerticalResponse has an active user community where you can ask questions, share tips, and learn from other users’ experiences. This can be a valuable resource for getting insights and solutions beyond what official support provides. They also offer webinars and guides to help you master their platform.

Mailigen: Robust Learning Hub

Mailigen’s learning hub is a treasure trove of resources. They provide webinars, guides, and case studies to help you make the most of their platform. Their blog is regularly updated with industry insights and best practices. For those who want to stay at the forefront of email marketing, Mailigen’s learning hub is a valuable asset.

The Verdict: Customer Support

Both VerticalResponse and Mailigen offer reliable customer support. VerticalResponse is great for email support and has an active user community. On the other hand, Mailigen goes the extra mile with 24/7 live chat, phone support, and a comprehensive learning hub. If stellar customer support is high on your priority list, Mailigen has the edge.

Related: Check out our free SEO suite

Integration Options: Expanding Your Marketing Ecosystem

When it comes to email marketing, it’s not just about sending emails; it’s about creating a seamless marketing ecosystem where your email tool can work harmoniously with other software and platforms you use. In this section, we’ll take a closer look at how both VerticalResponse and Mailigen handle integration options.

Your email marketing tool should be able to play well with the other tools in your marketing arsenal. Let’s explore how VerticalResponse and Mailigen approach integrations.

VerticalResponse: Good, but Limited

VerticalResponse offers a selection of integrations with popular tools and platforms commonly used in marketing. This includes integrations with e-commerce platforms like Shopify, social media platforms like Facebook, and content management systems like WordPress. These integrations cover the essentials, making it suitable for small to medium-sized businesses with relatively straightforward marketing needs.

However, it’s worth noting that VerticalResponse’s integration library, while practical, may not be as extensive as some other email marketing platforms. If your marketing ecosystem includes less common or specialized tools, you might encounter limitations when trying to integrate them with VerticalResponse.

Mailigen: Versatile Integrations

Mailigen takes a broader approach to integrations, catering to a wider range of business needs. Whether you use Customer Relationship Management (CRM) software, e-commerce platforms, analytics tools, or even custom-built software, Mailigen likely has an integration available. This versatility makes it an excellent choice for businesses with diverse and complex marketing ecosystems.

Mailigen’s extensive library of integrations ensures that you can seamlessly connect your email marketing efforts with the rest of your digital marketing tools. This is particularly valuable if you have a unique combination of tools that work together to achieve your marketing goals.

Leveraging the Power of APIs

While integrations cover pre-built connections to other tools, Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) take it a step further by allowing you to create custom connections or automate specific tasks.

VerticalResponse: Limited API

VerticalResponse does offer an API, which allows for some level of customization and automation. However, it’s essential to note that this API has limitations in terms of functionality. It’s primarily designed for basic integrations and may not support highly complex or specialized tasks. If you have specific requirements that go beyond what the standard API offers, you may find yourself constrained.

Mailigen: Extensive API

Mailigen’s API is known for its robustness and versatility. It provides more extensive capabilities, allowing you to create custom solutions and automate a wide range of tasks. For businesses that have unique requirements or want to build tailor-made integrations, Mailigen’s API documentation is a valuable resource. It opens up possibilities for creating custom workflows, data synchronization, and advanced automation that can enhance your marketing efforts.

The Verdict: Integration Options

When it comes to integration options, Mailigen stands out for its versatility and robust API. It offers a wide array of pre-built integrations and the flexibility to create custom connections, making it an excellent choice for businesses with diverse marketing ecosystems or specific integration needs.

VerticalResponse, while suitable for more straightforward marketing setups, may be limited if you require advanced integrations or have less common tools in your tech stack. It’s crucial to consider the complexity of your marketing ecosystem and the level of customization and automation you need when making your choice between these two email marketing platforms.

Deliverability: Ensuring Your Emails Reach the Inbox

Ensuring that your carefully crafted email campaigns actually land in your recipients’ inboxes is a critical aspect of email marketing success. In this section, we’ll explore how both VerticalResponse and Mailigen approach the challenge of email deliverability.

VerticalResponse: Focused on Quality

VerticalResponse places a strong emphasis on maintaining a positive sender reputation, which is a key factor in email deliverability. Here’s how they tackle the issue:

VerticalResponse enforces strict anti-spam policies to ensure that their users are sending legitimate and permission-based emails. They actively monitor email campaigns to detect any potential violations of these policies.

Maintaining a clean and healthy contact list is crucial for good deliverability. VerticalResponse offers list cleaning features to help you identify and remove invalid or inactive email addresses. This practice helps improve the quality of your list and reduces the chances of your emails bouncing.

VerticalResponse provides real-time spam checkers that analyze your email content before sending. This feature helps you identify potential spam triggers and make necessary adjustments to ensure that your emails have a higher chance of reaching the inbox.

Mailigen: Deliverability Expertise

Mailigen is known for its expertise in email deliverability. They go the extra mile to ensure that your emails have the best chance of landing in the inbox:

Mailigen has dedicated teams focused on maintaining sender reputation and ensuring high deliverability rates. These teams actively monitor email campaigns and take action to address any issues that could negatively impact deliverability.

Mailigen provides tools and settings to help you properly authenticate your emails. Authentication, including SPF (Sender Policy Framework) and DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail), adds a layer of trustworthiness to your emails in the eyes of ISPs.

Mailigen offers domain verification features to prove the legitimacy of your sending domains. This verification process helps establish your credibility as a sender.

Mailigen provides feedback loops with ISPs, which means that they have established communication channels with major email service providers. This allows you to receive notifications about email complaints, such as when recipients mark your emails as spam. By addressing complaints promptly, you can maintain a good sender reputation.

The Importance of Email Authentication

Email authentication protocols like SPF and DKIM play a significant role in email deliverability. They help ISPs verify the authenticity of the sender and reduce the likelihood of your emails being marked as spam.

VerticalResponse supports email authentication protocols like SPF and DKIM. Implementing these protocols is crucial for increasing the trustworthiness of your emails in the eyes of ISPs.

Mailigen provides robust support for email authentication protocols. They offer guidance and settings to help you configure SPF and DKIM correctly. This ensures that your emails are authenticated and less likely to be flagged as spam.

The Verdict: Deliverability

Both VerticalResponse and Mailigen take email deliverability seriously and have measures in place to enhance it. However, Mailigen’s specialized deliverability teams, strong support for authentication protocols, and feedback loops with ISPs give it a significant advantage when it comes to ensuring that your emails reach the inbox.

Deliverability is a critical factor in the success of your email marketing campaigns. Even the most compelling content won’t yield results if it doesn’t reach your audience. Therefore, if stellar email deliverability is a top priority for you, Mailigen’s expertise and proactive approach make it the preferred choice.

Reporting and Analytics: Measuring Email Marketing Success

Measuring the effectiveness of your email marketing campaigns is crucial for making data-driven decisions and optimizing your strategies. In this section, we’ll dive deep into how both VerticalResponse and Mailigen approach reporting and analytics.

Effective email marketing goes beyond just sending emails; it involves understanding how your campaigns are performing, what resonates with your audience, and where improvements can be made.

VerticalResponse: Basic Insights

VerticalResponse provides a set of essential reporting metrics that give you insights into the performance of your email campaigns. Here’s a closer look at what they offer:

VerticalResponse includes standard email marketing metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and bounce rates. These metrics help you gauge how well your emails are engaging your audience and identify potential issues.

The reporting dashboard in VerticalResponse is designed to be user-friendly, presenting your campaign data in a visually intuitive way. This makes it easy for users, even those without extensive analytical backgrounds, to understand their email performance at a glance.

The data provided by VerticalResponse’s reporting tools is sufficient for most small to medium-sized businesses. It allows you to track key performance indicators and make informed decisions about your email marketing strategy.

Mailigen: Data Galore

Mailigen takes reporting and analytics to the next level by offering a comprehensive suite of tools and insights:

In addition to the standard metrics, Mailigen provides extensive insights into subscriber behavior, engagement over time, and geographic data. You can dive deep into how your audience interacts with your emails, helping you understand what content resonates most.

Mailigen offers click heat maps, a powerful visual tool that displays where subscribers are clicking within your emails. This feature provides a granular view of user engagement, allowing you to identify which elements of your emails are most effective.

Mailigen goes beyond email-centric analytics by providing web behavior tracking. This feature allows you to track how email recipients interact with your website after clicking through from an email. It’s a valuable tool for understanding the full customer journey.

Mailigen’s A/B testing capabilities are advanced, allowing you to test various aspects of your campaigns, including different email content, send times, subject lines, and more. This level of testing empowers you to optimize your campaigns effectively.

The Verdict: Reporting and Analytics

In the realm of reporting and analytics, Mailigen stands out as the platform that provides in-depth insights and advanced tools. Its extensive metrics, click heat maps, web behavior tracking, and advanced A/B testing options allow marketers to gain a deep understanding of their email campaign performance and make data-driven decisions.

On the other hand, VerticalResponse offers simpler and more basic reporting tools that are suitable for businesses with straightforward email marketing needs. While VerticalResponse’s reporting is user-friendly and provides essential data, it may lack the depth and granularity that data-driven marketers seek.

Conclusion

Congratulations on making it through this in-depth comparison of VerticalResponse and Mailigen! You’ve gained a comprehensive understanding of these two email marketing tools, covering various aspects from usability to pricing, customer support to deliverability, and reporting to integrations. Now, let’s wrap it up and help you make an informed decision.

VerticalResponse is the go-to option if you prioritize simplicity, ease of use, and affordability. It’s perfect for small businesses, beginners, or anyone who wants to get started with email marketing quickly. Its drag-and-drop interface, straightforward pricing, and decent customer support make it a solid choice for those with basic email marketing needs.

On the other hand, Mailigen is the choice for those who demand a feature-rich platform, advanced automation, and in-depth analytics. It’s suitable for medium to large businesses or marketers looking to implement complex email marketing strategies. While it comes at a higher price point, the investment can be justified by its versatile integrations, powerful API, and excellent customer support.

Ultimately, the choice between VerticalResponse and Mailigen depends on your specific needs, goals, and budget. Consider what aspects are most important to your email marketing strategy, and weigh the pros and cons accordingly. Both tools have their strengths, and either can be a valuable asset to your marketing efforts.

Read Next:

• Special Holiday SEO Strategies for Travel Websites
• Future of Voice Assistants in Travel and Hospitality SEO
• How Machine Learning is Shaping SEO in Travel
• AI and Personalization in the Travel Industry’s SEO
• Voice Search SEO Strategies for Travel Businesses