This Article has been revised, edited and added to, by Poulomi Chakraborty.
- Comparing Traditional Marketing with Affiliate Marketing in Education
- Setting Up an Affiliate Program for Educational Courses
- Marketing Strategies and Promotional Tips for Engaging Potential Affiliates
- Develop a Compelling Affiliate Invitation
- Utilize Effective Communication Channels
- Offer Exclusive Deals for Affiliates to Promote
- Organize Affiliate Webinars or Workshops
- Keep Affiliates Engaged with Regular Updates and Incentives
- Track and Share Success Stories
- Crafting a Unique Affiliate Value Proposition
- Building Relationships Through Personal Engagement
- Leveraging Technology for Enhanced Affiliate Interaction
- Implementing Dynamic and Flexible Commission Structures
- Continuously Innovating Your Affiliate Offerings
- Prioritizing Clear and Consistent Communication
- Advanced Techniques for Scaling Your Affiliate Program
- Segment Your Affiliates for Targeted Strategies
- Leverage Affiliate Data for Insights
- Expand Your Affiliate Network
- Introduce Tiered Incentive Programs
- Utilize Automation Tools
- Foster a Community Among Affiliates
- Regularly Review and Adjust Your Program
- Enhancing Affiliate Onboarding and Training
- Integrating Advanced Segmentation and Personalization
- Exploiting Synergies with Other Marketing Channels
- Implementing Predictive Analytics and Machine Learning
- Developing a Feedback-Driven Culture
- Cultivating Strategic Brand Partnerships
- Leveraging Partnerships in Educational Affiliate Marketing
- Integrating Technology into Your Educational Affiliate Marketing Efforts
- Conclusion
In the world of education, finding effective ways to reach learners and institutions is key to success. Affiliate marketing, often overlooked, holds tremendous potential for course creators and educational tool developers. This approach not only amplifies your reach but also connects your products with the audiences that need them the most. Today, we’ll dive into how you can harness the power of affiliate marketing to promote educational resources, ensuring your offerings make the biggest impact possible.
Comparing Traditional Marketing with Affiliate Marketing in Education
Understanding Traditional Marketing in Education
Traditional marketing in the education sector has always been about visibility and brand recognition. This includes a range of strategies from print ads in educational magazines to booths at industry conferences. Typically, these methods focus on broad messages aimed at large audiences, seeking to cast as wide a net as possible.
The core idea is straightforward: the more people see your educational product, the higher the likelihood of converting a fraction of that audience into customers. This spray-and-pray approach can be effective but often comes at a high cost, both in terms of budget and resource allocation.
Furthermore, the lack of targeting can lead to inefficient spending, where much of the advertising reaches those who have no interest or need for the educational tools being promoted.
The Rise of Affiliate Marketing
Affiliate marketing introduces a more targeted strategy. It involves partnering with individuals or companies (affiliates) who promote your courses or tools to their established audience.
These affiliates could be bloggers, educators, industry experts, or even other businesses whose offerings complement your own. The beauty of this model lies in its performance-based structure: affiliates are typically compensated through a commission based on the sales or leads they generate, making it a lower-risk and cost-effective method.
In the education sector, where niche markets can be particularly pronounced, affiliate marketing allows for a precision approach. Instead of spending extensively on broad-spectrum advertising, you invest in relationships with affiliates who speak directly to the segments of the market most likely to be interested in your product.
For instance, a company selling advanced mathematical tools can partner with math blogging sites, educational YouTube channels, or math tutor networks.
Key Differences and Advantages
The primary difference between traditional and affiliate marketing in the education sector is the shift from quantity to quality. Traditional methods prioritize volume, pushing your message to as many eyes as possible.
Affiliate marketing, on the other hand, emphasizes relevance and engagement, focusing on creating meaningful connections through trusted sources.
One of the main advantages of affiliate marketing is cost efficiency. Since you’re only paying for successful conversions, your marketing budget is used more effectively. You’re not spending money to shout into the void; instead, you’re investing it into channels that have proven access to your target audience.
Expanding Reach vs. Building Depth
Traditional marketing techniques in the education sector typically focus on expanding reach through widespread advertising efforts, such as billboards, print ads, and television commercials.
This broad approach aims to cover as much ground as possible, often targeting a general audience which may or may not have a vested interest in educational advancements. While this can build brand awareness on a large scale, it does not guarantee engagement or conversion, particularly in niche markets that require more specialized knowledge and approaches.
In contrast, affiliate marketing offers a more focused strategy that builds depth in connections through targeted networks. For startup founders in the education sector, this means engaging with partners who already have the trust and attention of your ideal customers.
For instance, a startup offering a new STEM curriculum can partner with science education bloggers, technology education platforms, or e-learning influencers who specifically address audiences interested in these subjects.
Strategic Implementation for Startup Founders
To strategically implement affiliate marketing, startup founders should first thoroughly understand their audience segments. This involves identifying not only who the customers are but also where they spend their time online and what educational content they consume.
With this information, founders can strategically select affiliates who align with their brand’s values and customer interests, ensuring that each marketing effort is precisely targeted.
Once suitable affiliates are identified, the next step is crafting compelling narratives that affiliates can use to promote the products effectively. Unlike traditional marketing, where the message may be more general, affiliate content should be highly customized to the audience’s interests and needs.
For example, if your educational product is an app that helps children learn to read, providing affiliates with personal stories, user testimonials, and specific use cases can make the promotions more relatable and effective.
Another key aspect is the strategic use of incentives. While traditional marketing might rely on general sales and seasonal promotions, affiliate marketing can benefit from exclusive offers tailored for specific audiences, like back-to-school discounts, buy-one-get-one-free deals for educational tools, or special access to supplementary content.
These offers not only encourage sales but also add value to the promotions made by affiliates, making it more attractive for their followers to click through and make a purchase.
Harnessing Analytics for Optimized Results
A significant advantage of affiliate marketing over traditional methods is the ability to track and measure the effectiveness of each affiliate’s efforts. Startup founders should invest in robust analytics tools to monitor where traffic is coming from, which affiliates are performing best, and what types of content lead to conversions.
This data is invaluable as it allows for real-time adjustments to strategies, optimizing marketing spend, and refining affiliate relationships continuously.
Furthermore, feedback loops between the startup and its affiliates can be a game-changer. Regularly scheduled feedback sessions can help both parties understand what is working and what isn’t, leading to more effective promotions and innovations in product offerings.
Setting Up an Affiliate Program for Educational Courses
Step 1: Define Your Goals and Objectives
Before launching an affiliate program, it’s crucial to establish what you hope to achieve. Are you looking to increase enrollment in specific courses? Do you want to raise awareness of a new learning tool? Setting clear, measurable goals will guide your program’s structure and help you determine the success of your efforts.
Step 2: Choose the Right Affiliate Platform
Selecting an appropriate affiliate platform is foundational. There are several platforms available that cater to different needs and budgets, including ShareASale, Commission Junction, and ClickBank. These platforms facilitate management of your affiliates, tracking of sales or leads, and payment distribution. Choose one that is reputable and aligns with the size and scope of your educational offerings.
Step 3: Identify and Recruit Suitable Affiliates
The next step is finding and recruiting affiliates who can effectively promote your courses. Look for partners who:
- Have an audience that matches your target demographic.
- Share content related to education or your specific subject matter.
- Demonstrate engagement with their audience through comments, shares, and other interactions.
You can find potential affiliates by searching for educational content creators on platforms like YouTube, blogs, and social media, or by reaching out to educators and industry professionals directly.
Step 4: Create Attractive Commission Structures
Your commission structure is a vital part of your affiliate program. It needs to be competitive enough to attract quality affiliates but also sustainable for your business. A common practice is to offer a percentage of sales. For example, you might offer a 10% commission on all sales generated through affiliate links. Alternatively, for higher-priced courses, a fixed amount per sale might be more enticing.
Step 5: Provide Resources and Support
To maximize the effectiveness of your affiliates, provide them with all the necessary tools to succeed. This includes:
- Detailed information about the courses or products they will be promoting.
- Access to marketing materials such as banners, logos, and sample posts.
- Regular updates about new courses, promotions, and changes to your offerings.
Supporting your affiliates with great resources not only enhances their ability to sell but also helps maintain their engagement and loyalty to your brand.
Step 6: Monitor and Optimize
Once your program is running, ongoing monitoring and optimization are key. Track the performance of your affiliates, identifying which are most effective and why. Use this data to refine your approach, whether that’s adjusting commission structures, providing additional support, or even recruiting more affiliates similar to your top performers.
By carefully managing these elements, you set the stage for a successful affiliate program that not only drives course enrollments and product sales but also builds long-term partnerships that can evolve with your business needs.
Marketing Strategies and Promotional Tips for Engaging Potential Affiliates
Develop a Compelling Affiliate Invitation
The initial communication with potential affiliates is crucial. Your invitation should be personalized, highlighting the benefits of your program and why it is a good fit for them and their audience. Emphasize the value of your educational courses, the support you provide to your affiliates, and the earning potential. Make it clear that you’ve chosen them because of their influence and relevance in the education sector.
Utilize Effective Communication Channels
To reach potential affiliates, use a variety of communication channels:
- Email Campaigns: Tailor your emails to be informative and engaging, with a clear call-to-action. Make sure they stand out by using compelling subject lines.
- Social Media: Use platforms like LinkedIn, Twitter, and Facebook to post about your affiliate program. Engage with content creators in educational niches by commenting on their posts and offering them to join your program.
- Direct Outreach: For highly influential potential affiliates, consider more personalized outreach such as direct messages or even phone calls if appropriate.
Offer Exclusive Deals for Affiliates to Promote
Give your affiliates unique promotions or exclusive access that they can offer to their audience. This could be a discount code, early access to a new course, or free additional learning materials when their followers make a purchase. These deals not only incentivize the audience to purchase through affiliate links but also make affiliates more eager to promote your products.
Organize Affiliate Webinars or Workshops
Hosting exclusive webinars or workshops for your affiliates can serve multiple purposes. It helps educate them about your products, provides them with more content to promote, and shows your commitment to their success. These sessions can also be a platform for affiliates to give feedback and share strategies that have worked for them, fostering a community around your brand.
Keep Affiliates Engaged with Regular Updates and Incentives
Maintaining affiliate engagement is key to the long-term success of your program. Regular communication about new courses, changes in policy, or improvements in commission structures keeps affiliates informed and interested.
Consider implementing performance incentives such as bonuses for top performers or increased commissions after reaching certain milestones.
Track and Share Success Stories
Showcase the successes of your affiliate program by sharing case studies and testimonials from your top affiliates. Highlight how the program has benefited them and their audience.
Sharing these stories not only motivates existing affiliates but also attracts new ones. It demonstrates the effectiveness of your program and the potential benefits of joining.
Crafting a Unique Affiliate Value Proposition
For startup founders, the creation of a compelling affiliate value proposition is crucial. This proposition should clearly articulate the unique benefits that affiliates gain by joining your program, beyond just earning potential.
Consider aspects such as exclusive access to products before they launch, opportunities to co-create content or products, or access to special training and educational tools that can help them grow their own audience. By distinguishing your affiliate program from others, you can attract more dedicated and effective affiliates.
Building Relationships Through Personal Engagement
While digital communication is efficient, personal engagement remains a powerful tool in building strong affiliate relationships. Startup founders should consider arranging face-to-face meetings, whether at conferences, workshops, or casual meetups.
These interactions can foster a sense of partnership and loyalty that is hard to achieve through emails alone. Additionally, providing a personal touch like sending handwritten thank-you notes or small gifts can make affiliates feel valued and strengthen their commitment to promoting your products.
Leveraging Technology for Enhanced Affiliate Interaction
Utilizing the latest technology can significantly enhance the way you interact with and support your affiliates. For example, implementing a dedicated affiliate portal equipped with tools that allow for easy tracking of performance, access to promotional materials, and direct communication channels can enhance the affiliate experience.
Incorporating features like gamification, where affiliates earn badges or achieve ranks based on their performance, can also add an element of fun and competition that motivates continued engagement.
Implementing Dynamic and Flexible Commission Structures
To attract and retain top-performing affiliates, startups need to think beyond fixed commission rates. Implementing a dynamic commission structure that rewards top performers with higher rates or additional bonuses can motivate affiliates to put in extra effort.
Consider also offering performance tiers that allow new affiliates to climb up in terms of benefits as they prove their effectiveness. This not only incentivizes higher performance but also demonstrates that you value long-term partnerships and are willing to reward hard work and success.
Continuously Innovating Your Affiliate Offerings
In a competitive market, continuously innovating your affiliate offerings can keep your program attractive. This could mean regularly updating your promotional materials, offering seasonal or limited-time products for affiliates to promote, or even involving affiliates in product development discussions.
These efforts show that you are committed to keeping the program fresh and relevant, which can keep engagement levels high.
Prioritizing Clear and Consistent Communication
Clear, transparent, and consistent communication is the backbone of any successful affiliate program. Regular updates about product changes, new marketing strategies, or the overall performance of the affiliate program can help maintain open lines of communication.
Providing affiliates with a regular newsletter or a private blog that offers marketing tips, success stories, and insights into product usage can also help them perform better and feel more connected to your brand.
By focusing on these strategic and actionable tips, startup founders can not only engage potential affiliates more effectively but also build a thriving community that drives long-term success.
The key lies in creating genuine value for the affiliates, maintaining strong personal connections, and continuously innovating and adapting the program to meet the evolving needs of both the affiliates and the market.
Related: Check out our free SEO suite
Advanced Techniques for Scaling Your Affiliate Program
Segment Your Affiliates for Targeted Strategies
As your affiliate program grows, it becomes important to segment your affiliates based on their performance, niche, audience demographics, or the types of content they produce. This segmentation allows you to tailor your strategies and resources to better fit each group’s specific needs and potentials.
For instance, you might provide more advanced marketing materials or higher commission rates to your top-performing affiliates, while offering training and additional support to those who are less experienced.
Leverage Affiliate Data for Insights
Data is a powerful tool in optimizing and scaling your affiliate program. Track metrics such as click-through rates, conversion rates, and average order value. Use this data to identify trends, measure the effectiveness of your promotional strategies, and understand better what resonates with your target audience. This insight can guide your decision-making process, from adjusting commission structures to modifying your affiliate recruitment tactics.
Expand Your Affiliate Network
To scale your program, continuously look for new affiliates who can bring fresh perspectives and audiences to your educational products. Attend industry conferences, participate in forums, and engage with online communities related to education. Networking in these spaces can help you connect with potential affiliates who are already engaged and influential within the education sector.
Introduce Tiered Incentive Programs
Implementing a tiered incentive program can motivate affiliates to increase their performance. For example, you could set up different levels of rewards based on sales targets; affiliates who reach higher sales tiers get increased commissions or special bonuses. This not only encourages current affiliates to do more but also makes your program more attractive to potential high performers.
Utilize Automation Tools
As your affiliate program grows, managing it can become increasingly complex. Automation tools can help streamline many aspects of the program, such as affiliate tracking, commission payouts, and communication. Tools like Affise or Impact can automate routine tasks, allowing you to focus on strategy and relationship building.
Foster a Community Among Affiliates
Building a community among your affiliates can lead to a more vibrant and engaging program. Encourage interactions among your affiliates through dedicated forums, social media groups, or regular meetups. This not only helps in sharing best practices and success stories but also strengthens their commitment to your brand, as they feel part of a supportive network.
Regularly Review and Adjust Your Program
The educational market and affiliate marketing landscapes are always evolving. Regularly review your affiliate program to ensure it remains competitive and aligned with your business goals.
This may involve updating your marketing materials, revising your commission structures, or even redefining your target audiences. Stay adaptable and responsive to both your affiliates’ needs and market changes to ensure sustained growth.
Enhancing Affiliate Onboarding and Training
A crucial step in scaling an affiliate program effectively involves the onboarding and training processes. For startup founders, creating an immersive and informative onboarding experience can significantly impact the success and engagement levels of new affiliates.
Consider developing a series of interactive tutorials or webinars that not only teach affiliates about the products and how to market them but also educate them on best practices in digital marketing and content creation. This investment in affiliate education ensures they are well-prepared to promote your offerings, leading to better results and a stronger program.
Integrating Advanced Segmentation and Personalization
As your affiliate program grows, leveraging advanced segmentation and personalization techniques can enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of your campaigns. Use data analytics to segment affiliates based on their performance, niche, geographical location, and audience demographics.
Tailoring communication, promotions, and incentives based on these segments can lead to more personalized interactions and empower affiliates to perform better by targeting their specific strengths and audience needs.
Exploiting Synergies with Other Marketing Channels
To truly scale an affiliate program, integrating it with other marketing channels can provide comprehensive coverage and multiple touchpoints for potential customers. For example, synchronizing affiliate marketing efforts with your email marketing, social media, and even direct advertising campaigns can create a cohesive brand experience.
Encourage affiliates to leverage these other channels, providing them with content that can be easily adapted across platforms. This not only increases the visibility of your marketing efforts but also helps to maintain a consistent message across all channels.
Implementing Predictive Analytics and Machine Learning
Utilizing predictive analytics and machine learning can transform how you manage and scale your affiliate program. These technologies can help predict which affiliate partnerships will be the most fruitful, identify potential high performers early on, and even forecast market trends that could impact your strategy.
By integrating these tools, you can make more informed decisions, optimize your affiliate mix, and adjust strategies proactively to stay ahead of the curve.
Developing a Feedback-Driven Culture
Creating a feedback-driven culture within your affiliate program can lead to continuous improvement and innovation. Regularly solicit feedback from your affiliates on everything from the affiliate management platform to the promotional materials provided.
Implementing a systematic approach to collecting and acting on this feedback shows affiliates that their opinions are valued and that they have a stake in the program’s success, fostering a sense of ownership and loyalty.
Cultivating Strategic Brand Partnerships
Beyond individual affiliates, forming strategic partnerships with other brands can open up new channels and audiences. Look for companies with complementary products or services and consider establishing co-branded affiliate campaigns.
These partnerships can not only extend your reach but also enhance your brand’s credibility and trustworthiness by association. For startups, this can be a cost-effective way to access larger audiences and benefit from the established reputation of more prominent partners.
By employing these advanced techniques, startup founders can not only scale their affiliate programs effectively but also enhance the overall quality and reach of their marketing efforts.
Each strategy not only aims at growing the program but also at improving its sophistication, making it more adaptable to changes in the market and more aligned with the evolving needs of both affiliates and consumers.
Leveraging Partnerships in Educational Affiliate Marketing
Collaborate with Educational Institutions
One effective strategy to enhance your affiliate marketing efforts is to partner with educational institutions like schools, colleges, and universities. These partnerships can provide a reliable stream of users interested in your courses and tools. Work with these institutions to offer exclusive deals or co-branded content that can benefit both parties. For instance, offer a university’s students discounted access to your digital courses in exchange for promoting your program on the university’s channels.
Engage with Educational Influencers
Influencers in the education sector, such as popular educators on YouTube, renowned bloggers, or even authors, can be powerful allies in your affiliate marketing strategy. These individuals often have large followings of dedicated learners who trust their recommendations. Partnering with these influencers not only boosts your credibility but also directly exposes your products to enthusiastic, engaged audiences.
Develop Co-marketing Campaigns
Co-marketing involves teaming up with other businesses that serve the same market but don’t directly compete with you. For example, if your courses focus on professional development, you could partner with a company that offers career counseling services. Create joint campaigns where both parties promote each other’s services. This strategy can significantly broaden your reach and provide mutual benefits through shared audiences.
Utilize Industry Associations and Groups
Associations and groups within the education sector often hold significant influence and have extensive networks. Joining these can give you access to a wealth of potential affiliates who are deeply involved in education. Participate actively in these communities, sponsor events, or contribute educational content to their publications to gain visibility and credibility.
Offer Special Programs for Non-profits and NGOs
Non-profits and NGOs in the educational field frequently look for quality resources that can support their initiatives. By offering special affiliate programs targeted to these organizations, you can not only extend your reach but also contribute to educational causes. This could involve offering special pricing, donations, or collaborative projects that help promote both your brand and the non-profit’s mission.
Explore International Opportunities
Expanding your affiliate program internationally can open up new markets and diversify your affiliate base. However, this requires understanding the educational needs and marketing dynamics of different regions. Tailor your approach to suit local markets, and partner with local educational influencers and institutions to increase your program’s relevance and effectiveness globally.
Foster Long-term Relationships
Building long-term relationships with your partners is crucial for sustained success. Regularly check in with your partners, offer them continuous support, and provide incentives for renewing their partnerships. Show appreciation for their efforts and contributions, and always look for new ways to add value to the partnership.
Monitor Legal and Ethical Standards
As you leverage various partnerships, always ensure that your affiliate program complies with local and international legal and ethical standards. This includes clear disclosure of affiliate relationships, adherence to privacy laws, and engagement in fair marketing practices. Maintaining high standards will protect your reputation and ensure the longevity of your partnerships.
By strategically leveraging partnerships within and outside the education sector, you can significantly enhance the reach and effectiveness of your affiliate marketing efforts. Each type of partnership offers unique benefits and challenges, and navigating them thoughtfully can lead to a robust, dynamic affiliate program.
Integrating Technology into Your Educational Affiliate Marketing Efforts
Utilize Affiliate Tracking Software
Effective technology integration begins with the right tools for tracking and managing your affiliate program. Advanced affiliate tracking software like Post Affiliate Pro or AffTrack provides essential features such as real-time tracking, detailed analytics, and fraud detection. These tools help you monitor affiliate performance, manage payments, and optimize your marketing strategies based on accurate data.
Leverage Learning Management Systems (LMS)
If you’re promoting educational courses, integrating with Learning Management Systems (LMS) can enhance the value you offer through your affiliates. For example, you can provide affiliates with unique LMS features like branded dashboards or specialized content that their users can access. This integration not only makes the affiliate’s offer more attractive but also increases user engagement and satisfaction with the courses.
Employ CRM Systems
Customer Relationship Management (CRM) systems can be pivotal in managing relationships with your affiliates and customers. Use CRM to track all interactions, manage contacts, schedule communications, and analyze customer behavior. This centralized approach ensures that you maintain an informed, consistent, and personal relationship with your affiliates, enhancing loyalty and performance.
Implement Automated Email Marketing
Automated email marketing tools can significantly enhance your communication with affiliates and customers. Use platforms like Mailchimp or Constant Contact to send regular updates, educational content, and personalized offers. Automation ensures timely and relevant communication, helping to keep your brand top-of-mind and your affiliates motivated.
Explore Artificial Intelligence (AI) for Personalization
AI technologies can revolutionize how you tailor your marketing efforts to individual affiliates and their audiences. AI-driven tools can analyze data to predict affiliate behaviors and preferences, enabling you to offer personalized incentives, content, and support that resonate with each affiliate. This level of customization can dramatically increase the effectiveness of your program.
Integrate Social Media Tools
Social media management tools like Hootsuite or Buffer are essential for coordinating your marketing efforts across various platforms. These tools can help you and your affiliates schedule posts, track engagement, and analyze social media traffic. By providing your affiliates with access to these tools, you can empower them to promote your courses more effectively and consistently.
Use Webinars and Online Conferences
Technology also allows for interactive and engaging formats like webinars and online conferences to connect with affiliates. These platforms enable you to conduct training sessions, product demonstrations, and Q&A sessions that help educate and engage your affiliates, no matter where they are in the world.
Develop Mobile Apps
If applicable, developing a mobile app for your affiliate program can provide a direct and efficient way for affiliates to manage their accounts, track their performance, and receive updates. Mobile apps can enhance the user experience, making it easier and more engaging for affiliates to participate in your program actively.
By integrating these technological strategies, you can enhance the efficiency, reach, and impact of your educational affiliate marketing efforts. Each tool not only supports your operational needs but also adds value to your affiliates, making your program more attractive and competitive.
Conclusion
In conclusion, effectively leveraging affiliate marketing within the education sector involves a multifaceted approach. From carefully selecting and engaging with the right affiliates to integrating advanced technological tools, each step is crucial in developing a successful program. Emphasizing personalized communications through CRM systems, utilizing powerful tracking software, and enhancing affiliate capabilities with automated marketing tools are all pivotal.
Moreover, fostering strong, collaborative relationships with educational influencers, institutions, and through partnerships can significantly amplify your reach and impact. As the landscape of education continues to evolve with digital advancements, embracing these strategies will not only optimize your affiliate marketing efforts but also contribute to a robust, dynamic educational offering. By continuously adapting and refining your approach, you can ensure sustained growth and maintain a competitive edge in the ever-changing educational market.
Read Next:
- Harnessing the Power of Social Media in Influencer Marketing
- The Future of Influencer Marketing: Predictions and Trends to Watch
- Influencer Marketing for Digital Products: Strategies to 10X Your Campaign Results
- The Power of SEO in Influencer Marketing: Ensuring Maximum Visibility
- Influencer Marketing for Bloggers: Collaborations and Partnerships that Drive Traffic
Comments are closed.